The Model of Criminal Policy in Facing Political-Economic Corruption of the Oligarchic System

Shamloo, Bagher; Esmaeili Azar, Gholamreza

doi:10.48308/eclr.2024.234620.1050

The Model of Criminal Policy in Facing Political-Economic Corruption of the Oligarchic System

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Bagher shamloo ¹

Gholamreza Esmaeili Azar ²

¹ Associte Professor of Law. Shahid Behshti University

² Ph.D. Graduate of Criminal law and Criminology,Islamic Azad University of Gorgan ,Iran

https://doi.org/10.48308/eclr.2024.234620.1050

Abstract

Oligarchy or the rule of a small group with economic-political power or the power to influence the government has a long history in the fields of economics, law and political science. With their actions, this destructive group imposes widespread corruption on the society by extracting public resources for their own benefit. Researches and statistics of reliable international authorities show that the activities of oligarchs are expanding not only in developing societies but also in advanced societies. Daily news about the embezzlement and arrest of senior provincial and national agents in the country also points out the need to achieve a proportionate criminal policy in the face of this destructive phenomenon. Despite the valuable researches that have been conducted in this field, specific addressing to the issue of oligarchs in democratic structures and appropriate criminal policy has not been given special attention. Therefore, the upcoming research with "descriptive-analytical" method by explaining what, why and how to form the most important patterns of oligarchic system and its relationship with political-economic corruption in democratic structures seeks to provide appropriate criminal policy in facing this phenomenon. The findings indicate that the oligarchic system, due to its complexity and often organized, requires a review of the legislative criminal policy and the adoption of a differential criminal policy at all levels of investigation, prosecution and judicial proceedings, along with the employment of specialized officers and the use of active community criminal policy and Non-Governmental Organization

Keywords

Criminal Politics

Oligarchy

Political Corruption

Official mogul

Cartel building

References

Books
1. Fukuyama, Francis, Political Order and Political Decay, 5th edition, translated by: Rahman Kahramanpour, Tehran: Rozeneh Publications, 2022. (in Persian)
2. Gould, Julius & L.Kolb, William, A dictionary of the social sciences .Translation by: Parham, Bagher, 3rd edition, Tehran: Maziar Publications, 2013. (in Persian)
3. Johnston, Michael.(2005).Syndromes of Corruption:Wealth, Power and Democracy.Cambridge University Press. Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York,see: www.cambridge.org
4. Shamloo, Bagher, Criminal Policy, Tehran: Mizan Publications, 2014. (in Persian)
5. Shayan Mehr, Alireza, Comparative Encyclopaedia of Social Sciences, Volume 3, Tehran: Kayhan Publications, 2001. (in Persian)
Articles
1. Amundsen, Inge. “Corruption: Definitions and Concepts.Chr”.Michelsen Institute Development Studies and Human Rights Introduction DRAFT, 17 January 2000. https://etico.iiep. Org/ en/corruption-definitions-and-concepts.
2. Amundsen, Inge, “Political Corruption: An Introduction to the Issues”.Chr. Michelsen Institute Development Studies and Human Rights.WP 1999: 7, P.O. Box 6033 Postterminalen,N-5892 Bergen, Norway. ISSN 0804-3639. ISBN 82-90584-40-7.see: Web/URL: http//www.cmi.no.
3. Beheshti, S S, Moradi, R, & Paknejad, M Nr.” Sociological explanation of social factors affecting the perception of administrative corruption (case study: Arbab Rajoan of government offices in Yasouj city)”. Social Sciences of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, 17(2), 2019, 261-223. (in Persian)
4. Bosso, Francesco, Maíra Martini, Inaki Albisu Ardigó,“Political Corruption Topic Guide”; Compiled by the Anti-Corruption Helpdesk.TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL ؛The global coalition against corruption, 31 October 2014, with support from the European Commission. See https://knowledgehub.transparency.org /assets/uploads/ kproducts/Political_ corruption_ topic_guide_ pdf.
5. Cerqueti, R and Coppier, R. “Political Corruption. In: Marciano, A and Ramello”, G (ed.) Encyclopedia of Law and Economics New York Springer, 2019, https://openresearch.lsbu.ac.uk/item/896yz.
6. Dousti Zadeh, M. R., & Mazloom, B. “Lobbying Mechanism in European Union Legislative Procedure and Germany's powerful lobbies”, International Relations Researches, 9(3), 53-84. (in Persian)
7. Duc Hanh, Nguyen,“Corruption in The Banking Sector: Experiences, Challenges, Trends, Solutions and Recommendation”.Hanoi University for Prosecutors, Viet Nam, 2013, Pp:207-214. https://www.unafei.or. Jp/publications /pdf/GG12/32 _GG12_ Appendix _SR_ VietNam2.pdf.
8. Edgardo Buscaglia and Jan van Dijk, “Controlling Organized Crime and Corruption in The Public Sector”.Forum on Crime and Society, vol.3, Nos.1 and 2, 2003. Pp 2-34.
9. Esmaeli a, G., shamloo, B., & kalantari, K. “The risks of new technologies on social security with an emphasis on moral and value changes”. Police Criminological Researches, 4(12), 2023, 151-176. (in Persian)
10. Fjelde, Hanne & Håvard Hegre, “Political Corruption and Institutional Stability”,Studies in Comparative International Development 49(3), 2014, pp 267–299.
11. Golestani, Sh;Hatfi Mojumard, M and M. Elbinin Jalali, "Price leadership and collusion models in gas cartel using genetic algorithm", Quarterly Journal of Environmental and Energy Economics, 2nd year, No. 6, 2012, pp. 151-182.(in Persian)
12. Hassani, J;Mir Khalili, S M & Nazarinejad Kiashi, M R, "Study of crime risk management approach from the perspectives of Imami jurisprudence, Iranian criminal law and international criminal law", The Scientific Journal in Jurisprudence and Bases of Islamic law The 14 rd.Year/NO: 2 Summer 2021/ pp 109- (in Persian)
13. Heidenheimer Arnold J, Michael Johnston, & Victor T. LeVine, “ (eds.): Political Corruption”. A Handbook. New Brunswick NJ, 1989 (third printing 1993), Transaction Pub.
14. Hopkin, Jonathan, “The Emergence and Convergence of the Cartel Party: Parties, State and Economy in Southern Europe.Department of Political Science and International Studies”, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT UK.Paper for presentation at London School of Economics, 30 January 2003. See:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228404571.
1. Jamshidi Rudbari M. “An Investigation into the Incompatibility of Economic Models of OPEC’s Behaviour in the Long-run from the Point of View of the Evolution in the Crude Oil Market and the Basic Features of This Organization”. qjerp 2008; 16 (47) :25-63
  URL: http://qjerp.ir/article-1-264-fa.html/ (in Persian)
2. Javadi, Mahmoud, "Iran and Lobbying in the European Union: Capacities and Mechanisms", Foreign Policy Quarterly, 28th year, Vol. 4, 2013, pp. 703-728. (in Persian)
3. Kafi M, Shekarchizadeh M, Tavakoli A. “Differential criminal policy in unintentional crimes causes blood money in the light of the pluralism of the criminal justice system”. MLJ 2021; 15 :75-89,URL: http://ijmedicallaw.ir/article-1-1354-fa.html/ (in Persian)
4. Mirabbasi, F;Sai, A and Azghandi, A, "Corruption syndrome and fragile bureaucracy in transitioning societies", Strategic Policy Research Quarterly, 9, No. 34, 2019, pp 209-242.(in Persian)
5. Mozafarinia, S., Alboali, A., & Bavi, M,” Differential criminal policy to prevent juvenile delinquency in society, after leaving the institution with an educational approach”, Political Sociology of Iran, 5(11), 2023, 4568-4586. (in Persian)
6. Naderi, G., Abbasi, A., & Esmaeili, M, “Participatory criminal policies”. Political Sociology of Iran, 3(4), 2021, 1891-1909. (in Persian)
7. Niazpour, A, Criminal policy approach of the bill "How to manage conflicts of interest in performing legal duties and providing public services". The Journal of Modern Research on Administrative Law, 4(11), 2022, 219-242. (in Persian)
8. Niazpour, A,” Prevention of Corruption in By-Law of Systematic and Permanent Prevention and Reaction against Corruption in the Executive 2014”. Strategy, 24(3), 2015. (in Persian)
9. Niazpour, Amirhassan, "Criminological tasks of the judicial system in the light of the law of the fifth program of economic, social and cultural development", Legal Journal of Justice, 76, No. 80, 2013, pp. 193-222.(in Persian)
10. Shamlou, B., & Pakniat, M, “Differentiation of penal policy in the light of positive paradigm and its confronting challenges”, Comparative Law Review, 6(1), 201-226. (in Persian)
11. Shieh Ali, A., zare, V., zare, M, 'The Situation of Reflexive Participatory Criminal Policy in Penal Prosecution Process in Iranian Law”, Criminal law and Criminology Studies, 2(no 4&5) 2015, pp. 287-310. (in Persian)
12. Timbul Tampubolon, Tonny & Lele, Gabriel & Kumorotomo, Wahyudi, “Cartel and Political Corruption: Insight from Beef Imports Collusion in Indonesia. Annual Conference of Indonesian Association for Public Administration”.Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research, volume 122, IAPA 2019, Pp 224-241.
13. Wasisto Raharjo Jati, “Pemilu 2014: Kartelisasi Elite versus Representasi Publik”, Jurnal Ultima Humaniora, 2 (1), 2014, pp 45-58.
14. Winters, Jeffrey A. and Benjamin I. Page, “Oligarchy in the United States?. Perspectives on Politics”, Vol.7/No.4, December 2009, Pp 731-753.
15. Wojciech Konończuk& Denis Cenușa and Kornely Kakachia, “Oligarchs in Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia as key obstacles to reforms.Research and policy advice project”.supported by the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida), 24 May 2017. https://gip.ge/wp-content/uploads/ 2017/07/ Oligarchs _14-June _FINAL_0.pdf.
16. Zulfan Hakim, M & Jurdi, F,” Immature Politicians and Oligarchy as a Threat to Democracy”, University, Bandarlampung, Lampung, Indonesia, 11(4), 2017. pp 342-354. (in Persian)
17. Zulfan Hakim, Muhammad & Jurdi, Fajlurrahman, “Immature Politicians and Oligarchy as a Threat to Democracy” .University, Bandarlampung, Lampung, Indonesia, 11(4), 2017. pp 342-354.
Site
1. Person of the Year·2022 Winner: Yevgeny Prigozhin
.https://www.occrp.org/en/poy/ (2023/06/14).